I had been eyeing the blush pink boots for a long time and finally broke down and bought them, and planned to wear them in my sister's wedding. Lane ended up shipping me a pair of obviously used, damaged boots. Like, scuffed up, minor staining, missing emblem, chipped sole...etc. I tried to exchange but they were all out. But Lane worked with me to come up with a solution and I ended up keeping the boots and I love them. They also sent me a new emblem to attach. They are comfortable and beautiful even with minor defects. They do run a little small, given the snip toe, and I wish they sold a 10.5 ( for example I wear a 9.5 in the mules). But I've been stretching them out and they fit great now. If they hadn't sent me a pair of used boots and if they offered half sizes past 10, I'd give them a five. Other than that, amazing boots.